|
WHAT PRICE SWIFT GLORY??? (070300)
Subj: Buying a Swift
From: Robert Carver <rcarve@earthlink.net>
Monty, I'm considering buying a Swift. The owner has sent
me a list of all the equipment on board (IFR) which is nice.
But I am wondering about several things: It has "buckaroo"
wing tips. What effect does this have on performance, value,
or resale value? Aside from having a mechanic look at it and
determine airworthiness, general condition, logbook history,
A/D's , engine compression and last annual inspection date
what should I be particularly aware of? How do I determine
the real value of the plane vs the asking price? One last
one, where can I get a checkout in So. Cal.? Thanks, Bob Carver
Bob,
Look on the Swift site for flight instructors. I know (the
airplane), which was formerly owned by a friend of mine. The
"Buckaroo" wing tips are perhaps a close second
to the stock wing tips for takeoff and climb. They have a
reputation for being a mile an hour or so slower and of course
the roll rate is a little slower. Overall, I think they are
pretty good. The stock tips are pretty pricey right now, if
you can find a set. If stock tips do become available, it
only takes an hour or so to change them. As I recall, (the
Swift in question) was very clean and corrosion free. I must
confess I'm way behind on prices! I see some prices that I
can hardly believe on Swifts these days, but I was reading
an article on British Tiger Moths and they get $70,000 for
an overhauled one, and a Swift, I feel is worth a lot more!
-- Jim
(Editor's note: This question
for Monty came with the actual "N" number of the
Swift involved but not wanting to risk the sale I deleted
it. [It probably didn't matter but whatever...] Additionally,
when talking about how much Swifts are worth these days I
would focus more on what they actually end-up selling for
rather than asking price. I know that can be a touchy subject
sometimes but if any of you out there can send me email <arbeau@napanet
net> on what you paid for your Swift compared to the asking
price I'd like to share that information with the rest of
the gang. Thanks in advance... Oh, one more thing as a reminder
to anyone in search of a Swift. And we've mentioned this from
time to time. It is worth the effort and money to get a mechanic
familiar with Swifts to do a pre-buy inspection. To go without
that would be a rather significant gamble for an aircraft
that is over 50 years old. Swift mechanics and flight instructors
are listed on the GTS Homepage.)
YOU NEED TO
CHECK MORE THAN JUST THE USUAL THINGS...(110300)
Subj: inspection of aircraft
From: Don Cumpston <don@penn.com>
Jim : Do you feel there are other items that should be checked
on our Swifts at annual time that are not in the standard
items required to be inspected by the IA? I have a good mechanic
that I'm happy with, but he does not have a lot of Swift experience,
and I don't want him to miss anything. Thanks Don
Don,
Several things I check closely are:
1. The airplanes are old,
50 years or more. Check for corrosion, especially the vertical
fin and the outer wing panels. If corrosion is found, check
everything closely.
2. Check the cables for
rust, especially in the wing trailing edge area.
3. Check the horizontal
stabilizer front spar for cracks. With the wing/fuselage fairings
removed look at the first rivet outboard in the front spar.
4. Check the upper wing
attach fittings if you are not familiar with the airplane.
I still find GC-1A wings installed.
5. Check the landing gear
with the airplane on jacks per the reoccurring AD notes.
6. On a stock 125/145
engine mount, inspect per the AD note.
7. Check the rudder cables
for the specified 70 lbs. tension.
8. Check under the instrument
panel, make sure some installed instrument or radio is not
the elevator up limit.
9. If the battery is relocated,
be sure the master relay is adjacent to the battery box, not
on the firewall.
10. If an alternator is
installed make sure a 60 amp breaker is properly installed.
11. Check the early type
ailerons for cracks at the balance weight screws.
12. If the airplane is
a converted GC-1A, make sure the flap travel is 30 degrees.
I'm sure there are other
things which could be mentioned but these are notable items
from off the top of my head. Of course, normal items in FAR
43 apply. -- Jim
SWIFT RECOMMENDATIONS...(120100)
From: Gary Sigvaldsen <sigvaldsen@worldnet.att.net>
Monty: I currently fly a 737/300 for US Airways, and retire
in less than four years. My wife and I are thinking seriously
about getting a Swift, 125hp or more. Current thoughts are
"to buy what we want", not a "fixer upper".
Your thoughts and recommendations would be appreciated. Gary
S. Sigvaldsen <sigvaldsen@worldnet.att.net> Raleigh,
NC
Gary,
Hmm...what's a guy with a Minnesota name like that doing living
in NC? Seriously, the words most experienced Swift expert
flys for US Air also. Mark Holliday, do you know him? Mark
has several Swifts and sometimes sells off one of his collection.
I don't think he has anything for sale right now but it never
hurts to ask. His email is <MarkH85@aol.com> and phone
number is (651)770-3881. I don't think he's home today but
I expect him back toward the end of the week. I don't know
if you would be happy with a 125hp engine. A 145hp engine
is OK for a more-or-less original Swift, but the 210hp TCM
10-360 makes a real hot rod. There are various 150 thru 200hp
Lycomings in Swifts also. Of course, the ante goes up with
the power. A good 125/145 Swift goes for 30K to 40K, most
210hp Swifts go for more that 50K, and up to 100K for a showpiece.
I welcome further comment or discussion. -- Jim Montague
PAPERWORK:
DO THE RIGHT THING...(120200)
by Don Bartholomew <spectro@nanosecond.com> of The Aeroplane
Factory in Minden, NV
Thoughts about paperwork: When an IA does an annual on a plane,
they are responsible for the plane from the day it was manufactured
until the day they sign off the annual. To comply with this
responsibility, they must check all the paperwork that applies
to the plane. It is typical to get a plane in for an annual
and handed either just the most current log book (too little
information) or a box of paperwork that is 12" deep (too
much). If the IA has to sort through a box of paperwork to
determine what is currently applicable, they will spend a
lot of time which you will ultimately have to pay for. It
is common to find sales brochures, 337's, STC's, etc for things
that aren't even on the plane.
Here is a suggestion to
make life easier on your IA, and save you some money. Make
one book or folder that contains all of the current information
about the plane: 337's for equipment that is still installed
on the plane, only the current weight and balance papers,
only the current equipment list, STC's for current changes
to the aircraft, most recent AD compliance list. This needs
to be complete. If the IA can't find the approvals for a particular
installation in this folder, they will assume no approval
exists. Compare your paperwork to the airplane to see if there
is paper on everything that is installed or modified on your
plane.
Have another folder, if
you want, for historical data for the plane which contains
information that is no longer current: old weight and balance
and equipment lists, STC's and 337's for things that have
been taken off the plane. Keep a third file for general Swift
information and data. Happy paper sorting, Don
SWIFT QUESTIONS...(030301)
Subj: Swifts ...
From: Mark & Rhonda Oltjenbruns <moltjenb@bellsouth.net>
Hey Monty ,
It looks like you the Man ... I'm thinking pretty seriously
about a Swift. I have located a few. Is there anything that
I need to look for as far as maintenance problems ...landing
gear or ... Are you in Athens as in Tennessee ? I'm based
at Cherokee Co just north of Atlanta . I will be selling a
68 Cardinal 180 hp/conv . My plan was to keep it , but I fly
mostly by myself and want something fun to fly. What is the
average range in the swifts and cruise? Any info appreciated
, Mark
Mark
It depends. On any 50 year old machine it depends on how it
has been maintained. If allowed to get out of whack, the gear
can give a lot of trouble. Once it is properly rigged and
set up a few adjustments at every annual will take care of
it. I have had Swifts for 35 years and the gear actuators
seem to need "O" rings every 5 or 10 years and the
gear system needs attention perhaps every 500 hours or so.
I am located in MN. You have the "Swift Experts"
of the world not too far from you, in Athens, TN. As far as
performance goes, again, it depends. Just about any engine
from 85 to 220 hp can be found in Swifts. A 145 hp Swift will
cruise about 140 mph and with standard fuel, be good for 2
1/2 to 3 hour legs. Some "big engine" Swifts will
run red line airspeed (185 mph) and hold 55 gallons with aux
tanks. -- Jim
WHAT PRICE
SWIFT???(060402)
From: SteveWlson@aol.com
Subject: Re: Swift
(Editor says... Folling is Steve Wilson's reply to a request
for information about how much a Swift is worth...)
Bob... Nice to hear from you. I kinda look at what I might
pay for an airplane needing work as what it would be worth
completely restored or brought to the condition I might like,
and then work backward. Right now, a very nice stock 125/145
Swift in original condition will bring upward of $40K (or
more), while one in very average condition maybe $25-30K.
I know that most folks look at some of the work required as
a "Labor of Love" and I understand that; however,
I think my time is worth something. If you start by estimating
the cost in parts to bring the airplane up to the condition
you would like, and then subtract that figure from what you
think you might sell it for when completed, you will likely
come up with an acceptable figure for the current value. Good
luck... Steve W
WHAT PRICE
WRECKED SWIFT...(080202)
Subj: Price of wrecked Swift
From: Paul Chandler <paulisa@voltage.net>
Okay, Loaded question of the day! I'm wanting to know how
you determine the price of a Swift that has been set-up after
an accident with some parts removed and sold. What is there
is a fuselage in good shape and the center section bad on
left side. Also good R/H wing but bad L/H wing. (This is not
too unusual ---Ground Loop, Maybe.) Anyway no engine . no
tail feathers. no landing gear. I know it's not much left
to it but I hate to see one setting out left to the elements
when I know it could be fixed. I'll mention that I'm an aircraft
mech. with the tools and sheet metal supplies to fix most
any thing. Also have swift time from working with Nagle. I
tell this mainly so you understand the work would not be hired
out. Also this will be a weekend project over a long time,
mainly trying to keep the old bird from a sad death. One more
note and then I'll shut up. I 've been in planes before but
only in a Swift did we go up-side down and round and round!
Anyway, a reply will be great. Regards, Paul Chandler
Paul
Like you said -- that's a loaded question. It really depends
on a lot of factors that cannot be shared by mail! Also, it
depends on your ingenuity for scrounging parts etc. It sounds
like the most important, and expensive, parts are there. The
Swift that Mick Supina and I just rebuilt was damaged worse
and had more parts missing than the one you describe. You
day no engine -- how about the rest of the firewall forward?
Prop, engine mount, cowling, baffling, exhaust, etc.? You
say no landing gear -- how about the actuators and linkage?
No tail feathers? -- no horizontal, elevators, vertical or
rudder? Resurrecting that bird may depend more on your parts
scrounging ability, (and luck)! than your mechanical ability!
-- Jim
FUTURE CITABRIA
OWNER? (DEC 02)
From: jetdude76@yahoo.com
Hello,
I am looking into becoming a Swift owner and have a question.
I have been asking questions of current and past Swift owners.
Everyone seems to really enjoy or enjoyed having a Swift.
There is just one thing that has come up... A fellow who I
spoke with said he sold his Swift a few years back due to
fear of gear problems. Having never had a Swift I am confused
by what he said. Apparently, there was problems with his in
the strut or gear and leaking of fluid from that region. His
fix was to pull it apart and fix the culprit of the leaking,
but said that eventually he would have had to replace it and
since there are no more Swifts, it would possibly have became
a much of a pain and expense to maintain as his warbirds he
had in the hanger. I guess my question is, can anyone tell
me more about his concerns and maybe end my confusion as to
what part of the gear he was talking about? Hopefully I haven't
confused you as much as I am confused. Thanks, Future Swift
owner.....
The Swift is an old airplane
and certain parts are hard to get. But you can always get
them if you use a little ingenuity and are willing to pay
the price. Also, it is important to have a qualifiedmechanic
perform certain maintenance, like gear rebuilding and rigging.
No one starts out knowing all the answers but using myself
as an example, I learned by doing. If you are not willing
to do the same perhaps a simpler airplane, like a Citabria
which has no moving parts in its spring gear may be for you.
-- Monty
COLLECTOR
CLASSIC OR EVERYDAY UTILITY AIRPLANE... (AUG 03)
Subj: Swift Useful Load #'s
From: Eric Shepardson <ericshepardson@hotmail.com>
Jim,
I have enjoyed all the information you have put together on
the website run by Denis. I have finally decided to quit renting
and purchase my own plane. I have been a fan of the Swift
ever since I saw one at the local airport as a kid about 35
years ago. In evaluating my needs in a plane, I plan to fly
about 150 hours/year both business and pleasure with the wife.
I need a plane that has reasonable speed, (130 knts) and can
carry passenger loads of 350 pounds including baggage for
vacation. In examining data, it appears that Swifts with the
gross weight increase are at 1970 pounds, and most modified
Swifts empty weights are around 1450 pounds. With additional
fuel tanks up to 50 gallons, I can barely put myself in the
plane at full fuel let alone my wife and myself. how do most
Swift owners operate their planes? On only 20 gallons of fuel
with frequent stops on cross country's? Also, do you know
of anyone who has put a Lycoming 0-360-A4K in a Swift? This
is the engine from the Tiger, which operates a fixed pitch
prop. I really love the Swifts, and hope I won't have to convince
my wife that it is needed for a "second" plane.
Look forward to your reply. Regards, Eric Shepardson
Eric
Most big engine Swifts with the gross weight increase to 1970
lb. can still be overloaded. I guess you would have to take
each airplane separately and run the numbers. I just did a
W&B on a 210 Swift, and with an empty weight of 1343 lb.
you could carry full main fuel (28 gal.) two 170 lb. people
and 100 lb. baggage. With less baggage and a smaller passenger
you could carry some aux. fuel. If the empty weight were more
(like 1450 lb that you mention) you of course have 107 lb
less to work with. With a full fuel load of 50+ gallons you
are indeed looking at a single place airplane or one that
might carry a 100 lb passenger and no baggage. The way I look
at a Swift it is more of a collectors classic and showplane
than a utility airplane for everyday usage. I will admit to
having flown Swifts with over 2000 lb. takeoff weight and
I cannot say I am comfortable with that. I don't know of anyone
who has used a fixed pitch prop on a big engine Swift. You
would gain about 30 lb. in useful load but overall performance
would suffer. -- Jim
SWIFTS FOR
THE TALL GUYS... (OCT 03)
From: Roger Harris <rharris@petrillolaw.com>
Hello Jim,
For some time now, I've been thinking of purchasing a Swift.
Last Saturday, I finally got to go for a flight in one. While
the airplane handled well, I did find the cockpit to be rather
cramped. Unfortunately, I'm 6'2" tall and quite long
in the trunk. What, if anything, can be done about this? Switching
to thinner seat cushions would be a step in the right direction
(this has often worked for me in sailplanes), but is there
any other way to obtain more height in the cockpit (I understand
that the seats are fitted over a fuel tank, so I guess there's
no easy answer in that direction)? I hope that you might have
a suggestion, since flying with my head always bent over to
one side is not a very comfortable proposition! Many thanks
for your kind assistance.
Roger Harris
Toronto, Ontario
Roger
Taller guys than you have operated Swifts. It might take quite
a bit of adjusting to the seats. There is no fuel tank ordinarily
below the seats, but there are STCed belly aux ranks that
fit below the seats in some Swifts. Take the lower cushion
out completely and see what you think. The seat back can be
made quite thin also. -- Jim
(Editor says... I pointed Roger in the direction of Tom "Tall
Guy" Numelin out here in California for some ideas. If
any of you have some advice for Roger please send him an email.)
TALL GUYS
IN SWIFTS... (OCT 03)
(Editor says... Our thanks to Bob McLean for taking the time
to write Roger on the tall Swift pilot deal.)
From: BobMcLean2@aol.com
Subject: Tall Guys in Swifts
Roger,
Was reading your questions about "vertically challenged"
swift pilots. I am 6'5" tall and have over 500 hours
in Swifts. Unfortunately I have not flown one in the last
five years.
When I first sat in a
Swift with stock seats, I thought that "this is not going
to work out" The original seats were overstuffed affairs,
and I really couldn't have flown the airplane like that (knees
in the panel, no clearance for the head, etc.) My omniscience
airplane partner immediately removed the seats and replaced
them with some unknown style seats which amounted to a board
and foam which was upholstered and fit down into the seat
bay behind the spar and the back of the seat.
I think the secret is
to get the seat bottom as thin and low as you can stand, get
the seat backs as thin as you can stand, avoid installing
a radio stack in the center of the panel, under the panel.
My airplane was always "a work in progress" and
I mostly flew it without insulation, or upholstery on the
cockpit walls. This gave my left knee a little more room as
well. Again the lesson here is to keep everything thin for
more space.
I flew for years a second
Swift which was upholstered, and was able to manage, but had
to remove a "catch-all" pocket along the left side
"knee zone" which fortunately was installed by snaps.
It also had low seats which fit into this area that I talked
about, and the "center" radio stack (mounted below
the panel, was actually "off center" by an inch
or two which helped a great deal (as long as I was in the
left seat.)
I have ridden is "plush"
Swifts where I couldn't even sit up straight (my shoulder
was nearly against the hatch).
I know tall guys can fly
Swifts. It can be done, without a lot of effort. You may feel
like your driving a kiddie car with your knees on either side
of the wheel, but it ended up being a comfortable mode for
me, and I flew many cross country hours under those circumstances,
with the lower, thinner seats. -- Bob McLean
|